What gives these progressions their character?
A minor tonic gives the melody a minor third to lean on. In A minor, the F and C major chords supply contrast without changing the home key. A descending bass line can make that contrast easier to hear. Tempo, melody, and arrangement still do much of the emotional work: the same chords can support a driving chorus or a quiet verse.
The progressions
i–VI–III–VII — the minor axis
The minor key's answer to the pop loop: four chords that cycle forever without ever feeling resolved. Hold a common melody note over the first two chords and listen to its role change.
| Key | i | VI | III | VII |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A minor | Am | F | C | G |
| E minor | Em | C | G | D |
| D minor | Dm | Bb | F | C |
i–VII–VI–V — the Andalusian descent
Four roots falling by step, ending on a major V that yanks you back to the top. Used from flamenco to "Hit the Road Jack" (A minor) to surf rock to metal. Note the last chord: it's a major V (E major in A minor), borrowed from the harmonic minor scale — that major chord is the engine of the whole loop, because nothing pulls home like it.
| Key | i | VII | VI | V (major) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A minor | Am | G | F | E |
| E minor | Em | D | C | B |
| D minor | Dm | C | Bb | A |
i–iv–VI–III — the slow sink
Swap the axis's order and the energy drops further: tonic, minor iv (no relief there), then the two major chords arriving too late to help. A writers'-room favorite for verses that need to feel like they're going under slowly.
| Key | i | iv | VI | III |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A minor | Am | Dm | F | C |
| E minor | Em | Am | C | G |
| D minor | Dm | Gm | Bb | F |
Two-chord sad loops
Alternate Am–F (i–VI) and sing one short phrase over both chords. Then swap F for Em to hear Am–Em (i–v). Two chords can leave plenty of space for a busy melody or a lyric with a lot to say.
The descending bass line
Not a progression so much as a move: hold the tonic chord and walk the bass down underneath it. "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" (The Beatles) opens on Am – Am/G – Am/F# – F — the chord barely changes while the floor drops out from under it, A, G, F#, F. Piano writers do the same thing in the left hand. If a sad verse feels static, steal this before you change a single chord.
Borrowed chords: where the extra ache comes from
Most of the chords above come from the natural minor scale. The Andalusian descent already makes one exception: it uses a major V. Here are two other ways to change a chord’s quality.
The major IV in a minor key (from Dorian). A minor's diatonic iv is Dm. Play D major instead and the song briefly stands up straighter — which makes the fall back to Am sadder. "House of the Rising Sun" runs Am – C – D – F: that D major is borrowed from A Dorian, and it's the song's whole color.
The minor iv in a major key. Flip it around: in a major key, turn the IV chord minor and watch the mood drop mid-bar. Radiohead's "Creep" is the textbook case — G – B – C – Cm in G major. B major is a chromatic III in G; Cm borrows the minor iv from G minor. Compare this with G–Bm–C–C to hear what the two changes do.
Writing with these progressions
- Slow is sadder, but not by much. The same Am–F–C–G loop is a stadium singalong at 120 BPM and a funeral at 70. Set the tempo before you judge the progression.
- Leave space. Sad songs breathe. One chord per bar (or per two bars) with an arpeggio or a sparse piano part will out-ache a busy strum every time.
- Let the melody argue with the chords. A melody that lands on the major chords' notes over the minor tonic — or refuses to resolve when the loop comes home — is where "emotional" actually happens.
- Write the key down. Minor ideas evaporate fastest because they often start as a hum at night. Capture the loop, the key and a voice memo together, or you'll be re-deriving your own song next week.
Ready to build the whole song around one of these? Our how to write a song guide runs the full process, and the chord progressions hub has the master charts for every key, major and minor. Working out what key a recording is in before you borrow its loop? Here's how to find the key of a song.
Keep the sad ones somewhere safe
Save your chord names, key, and tempo alongside the rough recording in a SongRight note. That gives you a reference for the next session.